Judicial accountability is in fact a corollary of the independence of the judiciary. Judicial accountability, fairness, and independence. Judges must be free, but obliged, to decide on their own. Cole this article presents an overview of the explicit provisions of the united states constitution which relate to an independent judiciary, asserts the practical benefits thereof, and offers examples of ameri can judicial independence in action. In recent years the encj has developed a framework and vision of independence and accountability of the judiciary and a set of indicators to assess the state of independence and accountability of eu judicial systems. What is judicial independence the judicial learning center. International principles on the independence and accountability of. The survey makes a cautious start with regard to the accountability of the judiciary. The principle of judicial independence has attracted much attention and been critically analysed from a number of different perspectives and, not unexpectedly, accorded different meanings. Judicial accountability, which is often considered to complement judicial independence, is a fluid and evolving concept, the precise. The promulgation of the norms and standards for all judicial officers is one of the milestones that seeks to promote court.
Judicial independence, corruption and reform the icj is a worldwide network of judges and lawyers united in affirming international law and rule of law principles that advance human rights. James sensenbrenner and current ranking member lamar smith riled the conference with proposals for. It also aims to explain some of the practical arrangements which govern the way the judiciary of england and wales operates on a daytoday basis. Judicial independence and accountability in bulgaria. But judicial independence does not mean that judges and court officials should have free rein to behave as they please.
Independence of judiciary concept has however faced many criticisms and problems when it comes to appointment and transfer of judges. Mceachern, the changing face of the judiciary and legal profession 1995 291. The impeachment process is a powerful check that the legislative branch has over the judicial and executive branches of government. Judicial independence in the united states federal courts charles d. Judicial tenure, removal, immunity and accountability. Judicial independence and judicial accountability describe two competing visions of the relationship of judges to the rest of society judicial independence. Reconciling independence and accountability in judicial systems. Nature and concept of judicial accountability the concept of judicial accountability is as old as the independence of judiciary. That is, courts should not be subject to improper influence from the other branches of government or from private or partisan interests. E judicial accountability and discipline the judiciary needs to be independent of outside influence, particularly of political and economic entities such as government agencies or industry associations. Judicial independence and judicial accountability in the. Constitutional protections and political debates, 1 2.
Judicial accountability and independence legge rhythms. On the fragility of the independence of the judiciary see the recent controversy that arose in the united states on. Judicial accountability can be defined as the costs that a judge expects to incur in case hisher behavior andor hisher decisions deviate too much from a generally recognized standard, in this case referring to the letter of the law. The judicial accountability session mogoeng mogoeng chief. On one side of the spectrum are the stalwarts of judicial independence and on the other, the faction championing the cause of increased accountability. Judicial independence and the federal courtstalking points, 1 1. Judicial independence and judicial accountability in the 110th congress and beyond 3 chairman f.
Part one presents the conceptual framework for the judicial independence and accountability. Judicial independence and the federal judiciary federal judicial center iii contents introduction, 1 part i. This thesis examines issues of judicial independence and judicial accountability with special reference to public confidence in the judiciary. The cape town principles contained in appendix 1 are an attempt to set out such guidelines. Individual judges and the position of the judiciary as a branch of the state the respective responsibilities of the lord chancellor and the lord chief justice. Judicial independence is for judges what academic freedom is for professors. Judicial independence is the concept that the judiciary should be independent from the other branches of government. The role of judicial performance evaluation article pdf available in legal ethics oxford, england 61 january 2003 with 1,591 reads how we measure. Judges must be insulated against and independent from any and all sources of improper influence. On the other hand, citizens in general and judges are generally positive about judicial independence and in nearly all countries the trust in the. State of independence and accountability in europe. Lee the australian judiciary university cambridge press. One of the great paradoxes of the indian judiciary is to maintain the precarious balance between the slippery slopes of power and accountability.
Present in 70 countries across all regions of the world, the icj is. Judicial independence and judicial accountability in the 110. Judicial independence is a term that has two distinct meanings as it applies to matters of the judiciary. Judicial accountability is crucial in a democracy, ensuring that individual judges and the judiciary as a whole are impartial and independent of all external. Encj report on independence, accountability and quality of the judiciary performance indicators 2017 adopted by the general assembly, paris, 9 june 2017.
Judicial independence is not an absolute concept and there are many formulations of it. The principle of the independence of the judiciary entitles and requires the judiciary to ensure that judicial proceedings are conducted fairly and that the rights of the parties are respected. Politics of judicial independence in lesotho freedom house southern africa report prepared by rachel ellett, phd. The cape town principles contained in appendix 1 are an attempt to set out. Both these concepts have to be studied together to draw a proper line of balance between the two. Independence of the judiciary independence is a bulwark of rule of law. This section of the website aims to explain the importance of judicial independence and the consequences of that independence on the notion of judicial accountability. Ii independence and accountability of judges and adjudicators. Each one took an oath to administer justice according to law without fear or favour affection or ill. Independence and accountability the concept of independence of judiciary originated from the. A countrys judicial system is central to the protec tion of human rights and the preservation of the rule of law.
Renee landers cochair is a professor of law and faculty director of the health and biomedical law concentration at suffolk university law school. The promulgation of the norms and standards for all judicial officers is one of the milestones that seeks to promote court excellence and enhance judicial accountability. Pdf judicial independence and accountability in cameroon. The term is also used in a normative sense to refer to the kind of independence that courts and judges ought to possess. Pilot survey among lay judges about their perceptions of their actual independence. The approach has been extended to quality of justice as a high quality justice is the ultimate goal. So in what sense, if any, are they accountable, and to whom. As part of this undertaking a survey among the judges of europe was held about their independence in 20142015. Independence and accountability of the judiciary encj.
Independence and accountability of the judiciary and of the. Judicial independence takes various forms, shaped by different legal provisions, political traditions, and cultural expectations that have evolved over time and continue to inspire debate and selfreflection. Judicial independence is regarded as one of the foundation values of the australian legal system, such that the high court held in 2004 that a court capable of exercising federal judicial power must be, and must appear to be, an independent and impartial tribunal. Conceptual framework and existing discrepancies 1 purna man shakya sr.
This publication has been produced with the financial support of the justice programme of the european union. Judicial accountability can be defined as the costs that a judge expects to incur in case hisher behavior and or hisher decisions deviate too much from a generally recognized standard, in this case referring to the letter of the law. In canada, the independence of the judiciary has traditionally and principally. As a consequence, judges protection from undue influence or interference is a key concern and various principles and standards to protect judicial independence have been introduced by different bodies. Judicial independence was not intended to be a shield from public scrutiny. The impact of international law on judicial independence in domestic law. Orgsitesdefaultfileshistory itemsdocumentslatimer houseprinciples. Accountability without independence reduces the judiciary to a government agency. But judicial independence does not mean that judges and court. Independence and accountability of the judiciary evaluation of the use of the indicators.
The provisions in the united states to promote judicial independence on the one hand and to. Basic principles on the independence of the judiciary. But unlike the concept of judicial independence, accountability is an end in itself and applies to all three branches of government. Judicial independence and judicial accountability at the coalface of. Independence of the judiciary and separation of powers is one of the important and central tenets of the democracy.
The judiciary is not exempt from the requirement of accountability to the people it serves for the proper performance of its duties. Judicial independence is important to the idea of separation of powers. The independence and accountability of judges, lawyers and prosecutors vii freedom of expression and association 73 professional duties 74 disciplinary proceedings 76 part 2 79 i. Judicial independence can be defined as a characteristic of individual judges or as a characteristic of the judiciary as a whole. Independence and accountability the concept of independence of judiciary originated from the united kingdoms. Independence, accountability and quality of the judiciary. Independence and accountability of the judiciary encj survey. A view from the supreme court when i was lord chief justice i must have sworn in at least a hundred judges. The second edition of judges on trial examines the modern meaning of judicial independence. Appendix e survey among professional judges about their independence. The rules and practices shaping the culture of judicial independence in england are discussed as an illustration. Administrative justice and the independence of the judiciary.
Put simply, the rule of law can only be maintained by clearly defined judicial independence and accountability. Ohchr basic principles on the independence of the judiciary. Pdf independence of judiciary in india drprashant kumar. It summarizes the social interest in judicial independence and describes the indicators of. When we as judges speak of judicial independence as if it. Basic principles on the independence of the judiciary adopted by the seventh united nations congress on the prevention of crime and the treatment of offenders held at milan from 26 august to 6 september 1985 and endorsed by general assembly resolutions 4032 of 29 november 1985 and 40146 of december 1985. The accountability of the judiciary introduction individual judges and the position of the judiciary as a branch of the state the respective responsibilities of the lord chancellor and the lord chief justice issues and principles what is meant by accountability. Simply put, accountability refers to taking responsibilities for your actions and decisions. The central issues of this thesis are the tension between judicial independence and accountability and the ways the two conflicting values may be balanced in the administration o dehvef justicr e to. Basic principles on the independence of the judiciary adopted by the seventh united nations congress on the prevention of crime and the treatment of offenders held at milan from 26 august to 6 september 1985 and endorsed by general assembly resolutions 4032.
Judicial independence and accountability ballotpedia. A free dinner to anarchy and chaos may be a bit of a stretch. Judicial independence is important to you because it guarantees that judges are free to decide honestly and impartially, in accordance with the law and evidence, without concern or fear of interference, control, or improper influence from anyone. In the case of judicial independence, impeachment offers some security that if judges are acting in an illegal fashion, they can be removed from the bench. Judicial independence, the ability of courts and judges to perform their duties free of influence or control by other actors, whether governmental or private. Independence, accountability and quality of the judiciary encj. Securing the independence of the judiciary the indian. Judicial accountability and independence courts and. It is important that judicial independence and judicial accountability coexist and go hand in hand in order to maintain harmony in the judicial system.
Soumitra sen1 abstract judiciary is deemed to be a image of blindfolded justice holding balanced scales embodying the idea of impartiality and fair setup in it. Judicial tenure, removal, immunity and accountability 2. If judicial independence is guaranteed at the institutional level but not at the individual level, individual judges can be forced to obey the wishes of the leadership of the judiciary. Judicial accountability in india 2011 6 researching reality internship centre for civil society ii. The judiciary must be, and be seen to be, independent and accountable or there will be no public confidence in the judicial system and anarchy and chaos will shortly follow. The growth of constitutional adjudication and the need for judicial accountability require a renewed approach to a strained notion. The rule of law judicial independence and accountability.
437 15 1338 187 1280 514 1075 672 1439 554 829 1470 125 932 316 616 6 776 734 570 127 972 993 957 1234 1275 1514 818 1346 1680 999 36 438 1136 1017 243 668 708 443